Brewery Profile

Beer Justice Brewing Co.

For visitors exploring Arcade’s small-town beer options, this taproom offers a brewery with a clear local story rather than a generic theme. Beer Justice Brewing Co. grew out of a mid-life career change by co-founders Paul and Tammy, and its name comes directly from Paul’s service as Sheldon Town Justice during the brewery’s planning phase. Walk in expecting the judicial idea to carry through the branding and beer presentation, giving the space an identity tied to the owners’ background. Paul, a long-time homebrewer who pursued formal brewing education, serves as head brewmaster, while Tammy manages the taproom side of the business.

Travelers in this part of western New York often build trips around local stops: a meal nearby, a rural drive, a village main street, or a brewery that reflects the people behind it. This brewery fits that kind of itinerary because its appeal is not based on a large production story or a list of awards, but on the direct connection between the owners’ lives and the business they created. The concept took shape while Paul and Tammy were working from home during the early COVID lockdowns, and that origin gives the taproom a contemporary small-business context many visitors will recognize.

Because specific amenities, food options, events, and beer styles are not part of the available public profile here, the taproom is the place to confirm the day’s pours and any current offerings. Visitors should check current hours before making a special trip, especially if Arcade is part of a longer regional route. For anyone interested in owner-operated breweries with a defined theme and a local backstory, Beer Justice Brewing Co. is best approached as a straightforward taproom visit: see what is pouring, take in the judicial branding, and let the staff explain what is current.

The name Beer Justice Brewing Co. reflects the background of co-founder Paul, who served as the Sheldon Town Justice during the brewery's planning phase. Founded by Paul and Tammy as a mid-life career change, the concept developed while the couple was working from home during the initial COVID lockdowns. Paul, a long-time homebrewer, pursued formal education to become the head brewmaster, while Tammy manages the associated taproom operations in Arcade, New York. The brewery utilizes the judicial theme throughout its branding and product lines.

Website available

3 Hurdville Rd, Arcade, NY 14009, USA, Arcade, New York, 14009

Phone: 585-408-0006

Website: https://www.beerjusticebrewing.com/

Hours: Monday & Tuesday Closed Wednesday 4-9 Thursday 4-9 Friday 4-10 Saturday noon-10 Sunday noon-5

Upcoming Events

Upcoming public events currently attached to this brewery.

  • Beer Justice Brewing Co. Regular Taproom Hours

    Oct 7, 2026

    Beer Justice Brewing Co. is open Wednesdays and Thursdays from 4 to 9 p.m., Fridays from 4 to 10 p.m., Saturdays from noon to 10 p.m., and Sundays from noon to 7 p.m. The brewery…

  • Dart League Every Wednesday

    Oct 7, 2026

    Join the dart league every Wednesday. The new league begins January 7th, come participate or watch.

  • Beer Justice Brewing Co. Weekly Taproom Hours

    Oct 7, 2026

    Beer Justice Brewing Co. is open Wednesday and Thursday from 4 PM to 9 PM, Friday from 4 PM to 10 PM, Saturday from Noon to 10 PM, and Sunday from Noon to 7 PM. Enjoy a variety of…

  • Euchre Night

    Oct 8, 2026

    Join us for euchre every Thursday night.

  • Euchre Every Thursday Night

    Oct 8, 2026

    Join us every Thursday at 6pm for euchre night. Enjoy games and good company in the brewery.

  • Taste of Arcade

    Oct 17, 2026

  • Puzzle Night

    Oct 23, 2026

    A night dedicated to solving puzzles.

  • Flower Arranging Class

    Oct 25, 2026

    Participate in a class to learn flower arranging techniques.

  • Puzzle Night

    Oct 27, 2026

    Sign up in person for puzzle night to enjoy solving puzzles with friends and neighbors. Occurs multiple times in March and April.

  • Dart Tournament

    Oct 27, 2026

    Monthly dart tournament for all skill levels. Compete for prizes and bragging rights.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Beer Justice Brewing Co. located?
Beer Justice Brewing Co. is located at 3 Hurdville Rd, Arcade, NY 14009, USA, Arcade, New York, 14009. Use the map and directions on this page to plan your visit.
What are Beer Justice Brewing Co.'s hours?
Current hours are: Monday & Tuesday Closed Wednesday 4-9 Thursday 4-9 Friday 4-10 Saturday noon-10 Sunday noon-5. Hours can change on holidays and during private events — call ahead if your visit is time-sensitive.
How can I learn more about Beer Justice Brewing Co.?
Visit https://www.beerjusticebrewing.com/ for the brewery's own information about beers, events, and operations. Beer.Social aggregates public data and visitor-facing details to help with planning a stop.